Worst House on the Street Logo
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 1
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 2
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 3
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 4
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 5
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 6
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 7
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 8
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 9
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 10
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 11
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 12
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 13
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 14
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 15
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 16
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 17
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 18
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 19
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 20
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 21
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 22
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 23
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 24
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 25
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 26
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 27
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 28
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 29
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 30
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 31
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 32
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 33

Butterton, Newcastle, ST5

West Midlands

£725,000

Listed on 01/06/2026

Property Details

Bedrooms
4
Type
Detached
Area
2788 sqft

Description

Millstone House presents a unique opportunity for those looking to invest in a historically significant property that is ripe for restoration. Located in the charming hamlet of Butterton, this expansive residence spans over 320 square meters and boasts a fascinating history, believed to have originated as a village pub before being enhanced during the Victorian era. Characterized by its striking red-brick façade, featuring classic Victorian elements such as gables and bay windows, the property is an ideal canvas for transformation. Upon entering, you are greeted by a central reception hall with traditional parquet flooring that sets a grand tone. The ground floor offers three generously sized reception rooms with high ceilings and original open fireplaces—perfect spaces for either formal gatherings or relaxed family time. Additionally, the farmhouse kitchen is equipped with an oil-fired Aga and complemented by a practical side hallway that leads to a walk-in cool pantry. The first floor comprises five spacious double bedrooms, including two principal suites with dressing rooms, serviced by two family bathrooms. Outside, the extensive grounds include mature gardens on three sides, remnants of previously landscaped areas waiting for rejuvenation, as well as a productive orchard along the northern boundary. Accessed via gates leading to a sweeping gravel driveway with ample parking, the property also features a detached garage and interconnected outbuildings that hold great potential for various uses such as workshops or storage. Although Millstone House requires significant renovation and modernization efforts, it stands as an exceptional opportunity to create a bespoke family home in an idyllic setting. Moreover, there are plans for potential development opportunities on adjacent land while ensuring privacy for Millstone House itself. With convenient access to amenities in Newcastle-under-Lyme and Junction 15 of the M6 motorway just minutes away, this property combines the allure of countryside living with accessibility.

Investment Analysis

(ST5 area)

Above Market Value

This property is priced +12.6% above area average per sq ft

+12.6%
This Property
£260/sq ft
Area Average
£231/sq ft
Avg Rent (weekly)
£215
Avg Yield
4.9%

Renovation Potential

Heavy Refurb
Est. Renovation Cost
£100,000 - £150,000
Target Value
£708,124
10% above area average per sq ft
Potential ROI
-19.1%
After renovation
Note: Renovation cost estimates are AI-generated based on property location and general characteristics, and may not reflect actual costs.
Monthly Sales
67
Average per month
Market Turnover
17%
Properties sold annually

Local Market Trend (ST5)

Area prices are stable by -0.1% over the last 12 months
3 year growth: +13.4%
5 year growth: +32.9%
Investment Disclaimer: Analysis based on ST5 area averages and may not reflect property-specific factors like condition, exact location, or unique features. Any renovation cost estimates provided are AI-generated and should be considered indicative only. Renovation costs vary significantly based on property condition and scope of work. Always conduct professional surveys and get multiple quotes before making investment decisions.

Location

Butterton, Newcastle, ST5
Loading map...

Mortgage Calculator

£
£
£
%
%
years

Current average 2-year fixed rate is 4.45%

Current average variable rate is 6.60%

Monthly Repayments
£2,739
Based on a loan of £543,750 over 30 years at 4.45% interest

These results are estimates and are only intended as a guide. Make sure you obtain accurate figures from your lender before committing to any mortgage. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage.

Stamp Duty Calculator

Next Steps

Explore services to help you with this property purchase.

Get help with this property

Financing, surveys and more – choose a service and we’ll connect you with our trusted partners.

Allcott Associates