Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 1
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 2
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 3
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 4
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 5
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 6
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 7
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 8
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 9
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 10
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 11
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 12
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 13
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 14
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 15
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 16
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 17
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 18
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 19
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 20
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 21
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 22
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 23
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 24
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 25
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 26
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 27
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 28
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 29
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 30
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 31
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 32
Butterton, Newcastle, ST5 - Image 33

Butterton, Newcastle, ST5

West Midlands

£725,000

Listed on 02/06/2026

The listing

Property details

Bedrooms
4
Type
Detached
Area
2788 sqft

Features

  • Garage
  • Garden
  • Parking

Description

Millstone House presents a unique opportunity for those looking to invest in a historically significant property that is ripe for restoration. Located in the charming hamlet of Butterton, this expansive residence spans over 320 square meters and boasts a fascinating history, believed to have originated as a village pub before being enhanced during the Victorian era. Characterized by its striking red-brick façade, featuring classic Victorian elements such as gables and bay windows, the property is an ideal canvas for transformation. Upon entering, you are greeted by a central reception hall with traditional parquet flooring that sets a grand tone. The ground floor offers three generously sized reception rooms with high ceilings and original open fireplaces—perfect spaces for either formal gatherings or relaxed family time. Additionally, the farmhouse kitchen is equipped with an oil-fired Aga and complemented by a practical side hallway that leads to a walk-in cool pantry. The first floor comprises five spacious double bedrooms, including two principal suites with dressing rooms, serviced by two family bathrooms. Outside, the extensive grounds include mature gardens on three sides, remnants of previously landscaped areas waiting for rejuvenation, as well as a productive orchard along the northern boundary. Accessed via gates leading to a sweeping gravel driveway with ample parking, the property also features a detached garage and interconnected outbuildings that hold great potential for various uses such as workshops or storage. Although Millstone House requires significant renovation and modernization efforts, it stands as an exceptional opportunity to create a bespoke family home in an idyllic setting. Moreover, there are plans for potential development opportunities on adjacent land while ensuring privacy for Millstone House itself. With convenient access to amenities in Newcastle-under-Lyme and Junction 15 of the M6 motorway just minutes away, this property combines the allure of countryside living with accessibility.

WHOTS analysis

Our WHOTS verdict

An internal assessment of the opportunity to acquire, improve and create value.

43out of 100
Grade ELow opportunity

Confidence: MEDIUM

Millstone House offers a substantial period-home project, with generous reception rooms, fireplaces and parquet alongside extensive established grounds, an orchard and useful outbuildings. The dated interiors give a buyer scope to reshape and restore the house, while the gardens offer a distinctive project of their own. The asking price is £725,000, or £260 per sq ft against a local average of £235, so it is already dearer on this measure; with a heavy programme of works, the purchase price plus the work involved leaves costs stretched against local benchmarks for a house of this floor area. That comparison is with the local benchmark, not a forecast of the value after renovation.

Key opportunities

  • Rework the generous reception spaces around their fireplaces and parquet, bringing the period character back into focus.
  • The large established grounds, orchard and surviving formal garden structure offer scope for a substantial landscape restoration.
  • The outbuildings, cellar and generous house footprint provide useful space to rethink how the property works for a future owner.

Key risks

  • The asking price is already above the local £/sq ft benchmark, and purchase plus a substantial works programme leaves the project costs stretched against local benchmarks for this floor area.
  • A heavy, multi-room programme across the dated interiors will take considerably more time and coordination than a cosmetic refresh.
  • Staining on the cellar floor needs investigation; the roof and wider fabric also warrant a closer inspection, as photographs cannot confirm their detailed condition.
  • Headroom after works looks limited with the asking price plus a meaningful modernisation spend, about 22% ahead of typical local benchmarks for this size, so margin after refurbishment is unproven.

Unlock the full analysis

Sign up to see the refurb profile, below-market value, yields, and local market trends for this and every other property that has them.

Sign up free

Already have an account? Sign in

Interested in similar properties?

Create an alert and we'll notify you when similar renovation opportunities are listed.

Sign in to create alert

Map

Location

Butterton, Newcastle, ST5
Loading map...

Transport

Nearest stations

  • Stoke-on-Trent Rail Station

    3.7 miles

    Train · Stoke-upon-Trent

  • Wedgwood Rail Station

    4.0 miles

    Train · Barlaston

  • Barlaston Rail Station

    4.4 miles

    Train · Barlaston

  • Longport Rail Station

    4.7 miles

    Train · Longport

Contains public sector information from NaPTAN (DfT) licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Finance

Mortgage calculator

Illustrative repayments based on the asking price, not a mortgage offer.

£
£
£
%
%
years

Current average 2-year fixed rate is 5.13%

Current average variable rate is 6.58%

Monthly Repayments
£2,962
Based on a loan of £543,750 over 30 years at 5.13% interest

These results are estimates and are only intended as a guide. Make sure you obtain accurate figures from your lender before committing to any mortgage. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage.

Tax

Stamp duty calculator

Indicative tax based on the asking price and the options you select.

Services

Next steps

Explore services to help you with this property purchase.

Get help with this property

Financing, surveys and more – choose a service and we’ll connect you with our trusted partners.